Refund policy
Last updated: November 12, 2026
We want you to be happy with every card you get from We Got Nostalgia. If something isn't right, here's how returns work.
30-day returns
You can return any item within 30 days of delivery for a refund to your original payment method.
- The card must come back in the same condition it shipped in, in its original sleeve, top loader or case.
- Graded cards (PSA, BGS, SGC, CGC, etc.) must be returned in the original, undamaged slab with the same certification number.
- Sealed product must be returned unopened.
Return shipping
Return shipping is paid by the buyer, unless we made a mistake, such as sending the wrong card or a card that doesn't match its listing. In that case we'll cover return shipping and refund you in full, including your original shipping.
Damaged in transit
If your order arrives damaged, email us within 7 days of delivery with photos of the card and packaging, and we'll make it right with a replacement or refund.
How to start a return
Email us at wegotnostalgia@gmail.com with your order number and the reason for the return. We'll reply with the return address and instructions. Please don't send items back without contacting us first.
Refunds
Once we receive and inspect your return, we'll email you and issue your refund within 5 business days to your original payment method. Depending on your bank, it may take a few extra days to show up. Original shipping charges are refunded only when the return is due to our error.
Exchanges
Most of our cards are one-of-a-kind, so we can't offer exchanges. Return the item for a refund and place a new order for the card you want.
Questions
Reach us anytime at wegotnostalgia@gmail.com.